Talk:Islam

Islam vs Muslims

If the Islam page is unprotected again, it would be better to make the Islam page specifically about the religion (history, sects, beliefs, criticisms of the quran, sunnah, Muhammad), and the Muslims page specifically about the people, who are they and how they act, what they believe in and to what degree, and criticism about Muslims historically and today, in order to minimise overlap and future editor work.

--Cosmoflips14 (talk) 23:29, 15 December 2023 (UTC)

I disagree, on the contrary, broad subjects can and sometimes should overlap, many readers will only visit one article and be offered a general overwiew (without neglecting the focus), it is therefore, by such vast information, impossible to seperate a religion from it's worshippers. I think it is productive, to criticize Muslims within the Islam article and vice versa. --Crusader (talk) 01:04, 16 December 2023 (UTC)