Talk:Action T4

John Wear Article

Evidence for the German Euthanasia Program Compared to the Holocaust https://codoh.com/library/document/4885/

I have been asked the question: Why do you think the German euthanasia program happened during World War II, but not the Holocaust? This article will show that the evidence for the German euthanasia program is overwhelming, while the evidence to support the Holocaust story is severely lacking.

- Lamprecht (talk) 23:11, 24 October 2019 (UTC)

Suggestions

1 - should make it so "Aktion T4" redirects here

2 - Should discuss the alleged link between Aktion T4 and the AR camps. This is discussed by Germar Rudolf here:

http://www.vho.org/GB/Books/t/12.html

Under "1. Use of Euthanasia Staff during Operation Reinhardt" starting with:

In discussing the postulated murder of the Jews in the so-called Operation Reinhardt camps, of which Treblinka was the largest, historians of the status quo identify the technical and organizational origins of this mass murder as to be found in the program of euthanasia, which was enforced as of the beginning of World War Two - the killing of so-called 'life not worthy of life,' in other words, mentally and/or severely physically disabled people. The reason for this assumption is the considerable overlap, i.e., continuity of staff in both areas.[936] However, it seems to me a very dubious practice to attempt to construe this continuity as evidence for the mass murder, since it may very well mean only that the leadership had wished to retain staff, which had previously proven loyal in one socially extremely controversial operation, for a subsequent, no less controversial purpose. But whether this controversial purpose was the resettlement, ghettoization, or mass murder of the Jews, is still an open question.[937]

- Lamprecht (talk) 02:50, 22 October 2019 (UTC)

Germar Rudolf's argument is already in the article using another source. Upplysning (talk) 15:03, 22 October 2019 (UTC)